zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Broken Flowers (2005)

Broken Flowers
Man - getting nominated for all these awards is killin' me! I need to do a screwball comedy - I'm too old for this shit."

Starring:

Bill Murray
Jeffrey Wright
Julie Delpy
Jessical Lange
Sharon Stone
Tilda Swinton

Released By:

Focus Films

Released In:

2005

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

The Boneman

Grade:

A-


Broken Flowers begins as Bill Murray's aging, womanizer/commitment-phobic character (Don Johnston) is being left by his current main-squeeze (Julie Delpy). Don reacts to this development with the same kind of stoic resignation that has become the trademark of the (now Oscar caliber Murray). Gone is the over-the-top "but the flowers will all die" Bill - who suffered a similar fate in the opening scenes of Stripes. And rather than join the army, Don would have taken the loss in stride and moved on - were it not for the fact that Delpy hands him a pink envelope that she finds on the doorstep on her way out.

The envelope contains a pink letter from an anonymous ex-lover informing him that he is the father of an eighteen year old son, who has recently packed up a duffel bag and has set out in search of Don. Of course, Don is intrigued by the prospect, but would've been perfectly content to let the "chip off the old block" fall where he may, had he not shown the letter to his neighbor and friend Winston (an endearing Jeffrey Wright). Winston, a loving family man (pretty much the polar opposite of Don), insists that Don write down the names and as much pertinent information as he can remember about the women who might (chronologically) be candidates for the boy's mother. After a night of computer research, Winston presents Don with a coprehensive travel itinerary complete with plane tickets and Mapquest printouts. He also briefs him on his mission. He is to seek out clues as to which one of these women typed the ominous pink letter - any pink items (a pink typewriter is the ultimate smoking gun) photographs of a male child etc, etc.

Naturally it takes a good bit of prodding to convince the skeptical and set-in-his-ways Don to embark on such a potentially painful and patently ridiculous ride. But a lonely night in his now empty love nest, and the relentless lobbying by Winston is enough to let curiosity gets the better of the beleaguered Garfield. Murray has become so good at playing these very minimal, yet richly nuanced characters that you really can't take your eyes off him for fear of missing some fleeting facial expression that might either crack you up of break your heart. He inhabits these melancholy mid-lifers in a way that is so personal, that there is an almost voyeuristic element for those in the audience. He manages to portray loneliness in a way that doesn't inspire pity so much as it causes one to examine their own most painful existential questions.

While Murray's turn here is certainly a close cousin to his Oscar nominated performance in Lost in Translation, you can follow an arc of similar such morose meanderers - particularly in his collaborations with Wes Anderson. Though played more for comedy - the pathos of his lovelorn millionaire in Rushmore, his cuckolded Psych researcher in The Royal Tenenbaums, and even the brash Steve Zissou was rendered vulnerable when coming to terms with a full-grown son in Life Aquatic. A theme that he returns to from a much different angle in Broken Flowers. It would be a long and pointless debate over which performance is his best - I suppose it boils down to Lost in Translation and Broken Flowers, both films required of the actor that he convey so much of the story not with words but by his endlessly fascinating and expressive face. For example we learn early on that one of the women on his list had died several years ago and his visit to her gravesite is gorgeously heartbreaking. Credit director Jim Jarmusch for executing it to perfection.

Don's excursion into his previous lives and loves is endlessly poignant, at times funny, and quite frightening in several ways. The actresses he must visit in his Dickensian "Ghost of Cupid past" give outstanding performances. From the widowed Sharon Stone (who looks as stunning as ever) with her comely teenage daughter Lolita (Alexia Dziena) whom, as we all find out in a moment of well . . . revelation - is more than a handful. Stone proves to be the most cordial, but as Don presses on, his sudden appearances are met with less and less enthusiasm. I shan't go into very much more detail so as not to play the spoiler.

The other women that await him are played by Frances Conroy, a married real estate professional whom, due to medical reasons has been unable to bear children. She is married to her real estate partner, a convivial, but creepy Christopher MacDonald. Without explaining exactly why, this particular stop is truly the most devastating. Again much credit belongs to Jarmusch who has long been a master at making silence speak volumes. Jessica Lange is next on the agenda. She has become rich and successful as an "animal communicator," and has also written three best-selling books on the subject. This vignette serves up some of the best comical moments of the film - courtesy of a cat who doesn't like Don any more than Lange's secretary (a very impolite Chloe Sevigny). We eventually learn the reason for her cold shouldering, but I'll let you figure that one out when you see the film.

The last stop on his voyage proves to be the most fruitful in terms of clues, as Don finds himself a rather unwelcome trespasser in a ramshackle and filthy biker house. He is greeted by his ex-lovers new significant other, along with his menacingly large buddy (between the two of them they might have a full set of teeth). His chat with an almost unrecognizable Tilda Swinton is a short one and Don is escorted rather unceremoniously off the property.

I shan't give away any more - suffice to say that upon his return he has become quite obsessed with learning his sons identity - though he professes otherwise to Winston. Many will argue over the way the film ends - but in retrospect I think it was the perfect ending. The last scene demonstrates a significant change of heart in Don's Grinch-like demeanor, this coupled with the fact that he is in possession of the requisite clues - makes the ending work - however unsatisfying it might be to some.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Pollywog

Pollywog

I know what you mean about that dinner scene wtih the actress I've never heard of and the guy from happy Gilmore - man that was like something out of a David Lynch movie. Creeeeeeepy.

Jake Bringhurst

Jake Bringhurst

I liked Lost in Translation, but thought it was overrated. I loved Broken Flowers and hope he gets the Oscar for this one. If he would've won last year, he probably wouldn't have even got nominated this year - this is the year he should win - that performance absolutely floored me

Bruce J

Bruce J

Personally I don't see what's so great about Bill Murrays new acting style. All he does is stand there with a look on his face, if that's acting whatever, but I prefer it when actors acrually say things.

Adam

Adam

So the Boneman, myself and a handful of others actually hit a screening of this exceptional film before hitting a Ben Folds/Ben Lee/Rufus Wainwright concert in Sin City. What can I say? I'm in complete agreement with The Boneman on this one. So much so in fact, that I decided to write a little review on the film myself even though I'm way behind (my Brothers Grimm, Cave and Great Raid reviews should be up soon).

Broken Flowers is the latest outstanding offering from eccentric veteran film maker Jim Jarmusch (Stranger Than Paradise), and it is, perhaps, his most accessible project. This isn't to say that Jarmusch ditches all the

little nuances that make his films so unique. They're still here, but Broken Flowers presents it's situations with a broader stroke, and how could it not given that it stars legendary funny man Bill Murray.In this sweet, sometimes sad road movie, Murray plays Don Johnston (yes, there are plenty of jokes made at the expense of his name), a womanizer of sorts who, after a break up with a current girlfriend (played by Julie

Delpy), discovers that he might have a son by way of an ex-lover. Following constant persuasion by a friend (an endearing Jeffrey Wright), Don heads off on a road trip, hoping to reconnect with some of the many girlfriends

he's had through the years, so that he might find out if the recent revelation brought to his attention is true.

Bill Murray gives an exquisite, effortless performance, one comparable to his masterwork in Lost in Translation, but in many ways, this one proves to be more complex, as Murray spends more time reacting than acting. This is an extremely quiet, observant piece of work in which one of our very best comedic performers makes us laugh but with very little dialogue. And as the layers are pealed away, we discover that Don is a very lonely man searching for something much more than a son. This is beautifully illustrated

particularly during a key moment in the picture in which an emotionally crushed Don visits the grave site of one of his old lady friends. It's a subtle, cathartic moment, and Murray plays it like a true pro. Rest assured

though, the Murray we've all come to know and love does come out occasionally in the movie, and it is this gentle balancing act that makes this one of the best performances of the year.

Jarmusch is in top form here putting Murray into one interesting situation after another. Be it the free flowing nature of a luminous Sharon Stone and her attention grabber of a daughter, aptly named Lolita (played by a

revealing Alexi Dziena), the conservative rather creepy tone of Frances Conroy and Christopher McDonald, the eccentric stylings of animal psychic Jessica Lange, or the white trash surroundings of a bitter and insecure

Tilda Swinton, Broken Flowers changes tone without hesitation on several occasions, and that's one of the many things I love so much about it. In this respect, I was reminded of a less than stellar movie called White

Oleander in which a foster child is thrown into one home after another. Broken Flowers works in a similar but much more accomplished fashion. There will, no doubt, be discussion about the rather ambiguous nature of the ending, but upon reflection, I wasn't at all bothered by it, because (without giving too much away) this is really a movie about a man finding himself.

Broken Flowers is a smaller movie, and like Lost In Translation it's probably not a picture that will play to the masses, but for those of you who like a patient, thought provoking film with absolutely stellar acting, seek this

one out.

A-

Sarah Polley

Sarah Polley

Im really hoping this little sleeper creeps up and gives Billy boy another shot at oscar he got ripped off last time and this maybe the makeup call that sets things right

Paul Beilert

Paul Beilert

It's funny because I'm just 18 and have become a fan of bill murray b ecause of his recent work now that I've gone back and watched like Meatballs and Caddyschack it's like watching Woody Allen's early stuff

JT

JT

Myself I'm getting a little sick of Murray's reacting instead of acting - give me ghostbusters or Stripes, you can have your damn broken flowers.

Michael Bresqard

Michael Bresqard

I saw Broken Flowers with a few of my friends and the biggest problem they had was definitely with the ending. I agree with you, the ending while not offering any resolution, is ideal, in that you learn how he really feels and you see that the person that he is really searching for is himself. Still my friends wanted a reunion with the kid, but what could Jarmuch have done with that that wouldn't have been even more hollow?

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!