zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Lemony Snicket (2004)

Lemony Snicket
"Okay, so I'm a fraud as a mime - but I'm no Ashlee Simpson!"

Starring:

Jim Carrey
Emily Browning
Liam Aiken
Kara Hoffman and Shelby Hoffman

Released By:

Paramount Pictures and Dreamworks Pictures

Released In:

2004

Rated:

PG

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

B+


Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events is based on the series of popular children's stories, although I'd like to make it abundantly clear that parents should exercise extreme caution before taking their little ones to see this picture. It is dark, a tad morbid, and extremely depressing. Having said that, I was very surprised by how much I liked this movie, despite a meandering screenplay and a showboating Jim Carrey.

Narrated by fictional writer Lemony Snicket (Jude Lawe), this whimsical fantasy tells the story of young Violet, Klaus, and Sunny Baudelaire, three recently orphaned children whom, after escaping the evil clutches of money hungry Count Olaf (a high energy Jim Carrey), embark on a fantastical journey, hopscotching from one new home to the next, with Olaf hot on their heals.

A Series of Unfortunate Events reminded me of three other films in particular - Harry Potter with it's unique vision and magical vistas, Big Fish with it's whimsical tales of awe-inspiring fantasy, and White Oleander with it's primary story about parentless youngsters being put into one tough situation after another.

This is another one of those manic, go-for-broke turns by Jim Carrey, and he doesn't waste any time making it known that he's the star of the picture (granted it should be pointed out that I wasn't really annoyed by him here -his turn as the Grinch is another story however). Funny thing though, as overpowering as one might expect Carrey to be, he is overshadowed by three wonderful young leads in the form of Emily Browning (who plays the quiet but tough Violet - I see a star in the making here), Liam Aiken (who plays the wise Klaus), and cute little twins Kara and Shelby Hoffman (who share duties in playing Sunny, an infant who has a habit of biting things and not letting go). These youngsters hold their own against the likes of a bigger-than-life Jim Carrey and veteran star Meryl Streep.

Carrey is also upstaged by absolutely breathtaking cinematography, stunning Art Direction, and a magical score by Thomas Newman. I have to say that Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events is one of the best looking pictures of the year.

As I stated early on in the review though, this movie is surprisingly dark and I'm quite shocked that the MPAA didn't slap this one with a PG-13. But then, I don't know why I'm in the least bit surprised. This is, after all, the MPAA we're talking about. These guys gave The Polar Express a G (clearly, it should have got a PG). A Series of Unfortunate Events is definitely on the gloomy side, and not only features a murder attempt on the lives of three youngsters, but features a most inappropriate wedding as well. Still, I guess the title itself is something of a warning - after all it's not A Series of Fortunate Events.

As morbid as Lemony Snicket gets, I respected that the film doesn't shy away from tackling tough subject matter head on. Of course, it helps that this is fantasy, which to some extent cushions the blow.

Many critics are giving low marks to the meandering screenplay, and while I'm inclined to agree that the movie is a little uneven, the young leads and the stunning production values were enough for me. I wasn't as enchanted by this as the last Harry Potter film, but I still felt it to be a magical movie experience. And nothing could prepare me for the visual splendor of it all. Director Brad Silberling (City of Angels, Casper) has fashioned his best looking movie to be sure. And while at the surface, Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events appears to be a mean-spirited fairy tale, it ultimately becomes a story about the power of family. This is never more apparent than in the unexpectedly moving (and bittersweet) final moments of the picture, in which there does appear to be light at the end of the tunnel. I really got swept up in the fantasy of this movie, and I hope there are more unfortunate events to come.

On a side note, be sure to stick around for the strange (but cool) ending credits.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Jim Carrey

Jim Carrey

I am the most overrated actor alive today. Did you notice how I got a little extra credit for NOT ruining Eternal Sunshine? The same people who voted for Bush see movies because I'm in them. I love making million$ off of fools with poor taste and nothing better to do.

Sweety

Sweety

I don't agree that Carrey gets carried away in this film - the role called for his specialty and he delivered. It wasn't a role that requires restriant. I hope he gets recognition this year - he's one of our greatest talents.

nesta and Hana

nesta and Hana

Hello Mr. Director,

We are two of Lemony Snickets a Series of unfortunate events

readers weve read all the books from 1 to 11 at least twice

and own the blank book.We are not stupid.You did not be true to the books as much as you claimed.We are extremly disapointed that you messed up the movie.I think that you should have just put one book in the movie and put in all the details.And why did you make it a happy ending?the only reason that me and my friends read the books is because there different.So next time stay true to the books and make everyone happy.

p.s heres some advice on your future movies don't do any.

zoe

zoe

Id have to disagree with your assessment of Jim Carey's performance, he gave the film the vast majority of it's laughs and without them it would have been a pretty grim movie. I understand about how he hams it up a lot, but his timing and subtleties gave the movie it's edge. It was for sure a very well photographed movie and I also agree with your rating, but to say Carey was overshadowed is not true.

Adam

Adam

Hi Zoe,

For me, the children really made the movie. Carrey was decent, but I wasn't overwhelmed by him, particularly after seeing him in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. That's a performance really worth talking about. Never has normalcy been so grand. His Count Olaf was amusing, but, as is the case with so many of his trademark spastic roles, I always felt like I was watching Jim Carrey. Terrific movie though. Thanks for hitting the site.

Snick this

Snick this

Lemony Snicket is the film that Big Fish was trying to be. Carey was genius in this film and he was surrounded by greatness all the way around. Definitley one of the most entertaining films of the year.

Kayla

Kayla

i think it needed some musical parts

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!