zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Madagascar (2005)

Madagascar
"It's always the same with Zebras! Everything's clear cut, there's no gray area, y'know? - The way they see the world it's all cut and dried."

Starring:

Ben Stiller
Chris Rock
Jada Pinkett Smith
Cedric the Entertainer

Released By:

Dreamworks Pictures

Released In:

2005

Rated:

PG

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

C+


Madagascar is the latest computer animated concoction from Dreamworks, and while it certainly looks good, it can't hold a barbecued weed-rat to the likes of Shrek.

In this animated feature, Chris Rock voices Marty, a zebra in a New York zoo who dreams of a different (and wild) life. His buddies Alex the Lion (voiced by Ben Stiller), Gloria the Hippo (voiced by Jada Pinkett Smith), and Melman the Giraffe (voiced by Dave Schwimmer) enjoy their life of leisure and privilege - what's a bar or two when you're living the pampered life? One evening, Marty decides it's time to venture out and find the world that only exists in his dreams. When his friends go searching for him, a bizarre turn of adventure grants Marty his wish. Without going into the how or why, these four animal buddies soon find themselves lost in the wild.

Madagascar looks spectacular, and the tone of the film is more old school than contemporary (think Rocky and Bullwinkle), although some of the film's funniest gags (including a clever riff on American Beauty) are taken from more current headlines.

The performances are merely adequate. Alex the Lion is a fun and I got a kick out of how arrogant this character is. He is, after all, the king of the jungle and a scene in which he gives his buddy gifts with his face plastered all over them is a riot. Unfortunately, I don't believe Ben Stiller was the right choice for this part. Stiller has a dry wit, but Alex the Lion would have benefitted greatly from a bigger than life persona. Someone like The Rock perhaps. Chris Rock is a perfect fit for Marty the Zebra and answers that age old question; "Is a zebra black with white stripes or white with black stripes?" Schwimmer and Smith have a few moments of lively bravado, but neither seem completely comfortable in their animated counterparts' hoofs.

Madagascar has some really funny moments. There's a tip of the hat to one of my all time favorite Twilight Zone episodes, a funny bit with a couple of monkeys who constantly make comments about poo flinging, a cute running gag with four gangster penguins hoping to make a new life for themselves, and a clever (and surprisingly mean spirited) montage on the nature of the food chain. I also like the film's introduction to a massive family of lemurs who engage in a rave that proves the be much funnier than the unintentionally hilarious rave in Matrix Reloaded, as well as Alex's comeuppance as to his real status in the wild.

Sadly though, I was more bored during Madagascar than anything else. The fun scenes were few and far between, and ultimately, I wasn't terribly engaged by the film. Somehow, Madagascar just didn't feel lively enough, and a cartoon can't work if it isn't lively.

Recently, the computer animated Robots was criticized for being too boring, but quite frankly, I think it moved at a much quicker clip than this.

Madagascar isn't horrible. It attempts to offer up visuals for the young ones while engaging the older crowd with more adult humor. Unfortunately, this tricky balancing act never quite gels. It's almost as if it's trying too hard and as an end result, is only marginally entertaining. This computer animated effort looks stunning, but it hasn't the heart or style of the Pixar efforts nor does it offer up the terrific pacing of Shrek. Still, if the look on my kids' faces is any indication, it will keep the little ones happy.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Jason Bentley

Jason Bentley

Big Disappointment, I was bored to tears and my children were even getting fidgety. There's no greater barometer than that. If the kids are losing interest, thumbs down, period

Mad as a Gascar

Mad as a Gascar

Madagascar may not be as great as the first Shrek, but it's a hell of a lot better than Shrek 2 - come on that sequel blows and you gave it way too high of marks

Caitlin Barba

Caitlin Barba

This movie was great! I think it was better than Shrek because it wasn't gross or anything. Chris Rock was a perfect voice for Marty because he had the right attitude and junk. The movie was really funny, it had no nerd jokes, and EVERYONE laughed at it... even the seventh time around!

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!