zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Mean Girls (2004)

Mean Girls
Santa Claws

Starring:

Lyndsay Lohan
Rachel McAdams

Released In:

2004

Rated:

PG-13

Reviewed By:

The Boneman

Grade:

B


Mean Girls will undoubtedly accomplish one thing, it will solidify Lyndsay Lohan as a star. After showing a great deal of promise in Freaky Friday, Lyndsay Lohan's performance here requires that she manage a broad range of acting, much of it tip toeing upon the subtle thin ice of satire. A feat which she performs with flying colors thanks to a smart script written by SNL headwriter Tina Fey (based on Rosalind Wiseman's best seller "Queen Bees and Wannabes) and re-teaming with Freaky Friday director Mark Waters who coaxed the first effective performance out of the yet unproven Lohan.

At first glance I figured this was going to be another shlocky teen clap-trap with Freddie Prinze Jr. hiding in there somewhere, but when I heard Fey's name attached I suspected this might be something special. The story sets up an interesting experiment in human social interaction. Lohan's character (Cady) arrives in a tough Chicago area High School as the ultimate social "tabula rasa." The reason she's such a blank slate is due to the fact that her parents are zoologists who raised and home-schooled Cady in the wilds of Africa. The filmmakers make good use of the fact that there are a number of similarities to high school life and the laws of the jungle and they inject a few fantasy scenes to drive the point home. (For example the central fountain at the mall, is transformed into the watering hole of the wild.)

Upon her arrival the lonely and overwhelmed Cady is immediately befriended by a couple of social outcasts - Janis (Lizzy Caplan), a Goth girl who is ridiculed as a lesbian, but isn't, and Damian (Daniel Franzese), a gay guy who proudly left the closet years ago. Janis and Damian right away give her a condensed version of the realities of life in this new jungle - teaching her about "the plastics" who prowl the hallways like royalty and whose leader, Regina (Rachel McAdams) sports the most venomous pair of fangs in school. Quite amusingly Regina's court of bitches-in-training are a clueless twosome, who are nothing more than sycophants disguised as hotties who would be wholly unable to assume the duties as Queen Bee should Regina be suspended or transferred. It is a fragile framework that this social strata is built upon.

The plot really gets cooking when this framework is put to the test by our intrepid outcasts and their new hottie of a poster girl (Cady). As it turns out Regina takes notice of Cady and realizes that she might be of use in her "Regina regime," which gives Janis and Damien one hell of a good idea. If you've yet to see this coming, they talk Cady into joining the plastics on an undercover mission aimed at digging up some sort of dirt, or chink in her armor that they can exploit in order to topple the "queen of mean's" dick-tatorship.

It's at this point that the movie becomes tricky. With all this new found power at her fingertips Cady becomes enamored of the ways of High School royalty which threatens to turn her innocent and generous heart into plastic. This sequence also offers Fey the opportunity to expose these plastic princesses not as cut-out caricatures, but as young insecure girls confronting their own issues of self-worth and fear of failure. The pressure they are under is much greater than the common AV nerd, is the point she makes here.

The film's major challenge (and I think they pull it off quite well) is to keep the audience on Cady's side during her undercover odyssey. This they do by portraying it as a wonderful eye-opening experience in self-discovery. You can't blame her for reveling in her virgin turn in the cat-bird's seat, but Fey challenges you pretty hard as Cady becomes increasingly savvy about game-playing and much, much meaner. Fey deftly pushes you to that point where you're ready to turn on Cady altogether, or remain hopeful that the goodness of her heart has only temporarily become dormant. This is where this writer is going to leave you hanging. Suffice to say that I really enjoyed this film, and it is a film that a wide audience can enjoy - from adults to tweens. It's by no means a perfect movie, but diefinitley a winner in large part because of a very smart script based on a book with a wonderful premise and a marvelous star-making turn by Lohan.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Fey Fan

Fey Fan

Mean Girls is the funniest movie of the year, and what makes that so refreshing is that it has an intelligence, a positive message and anyone from Grandma to 7 Year olds can go and get something from it. Goodnight and have a pleasant tomorrow!

LL Cool

LL Cool

I had seen Freaky Friday and was pleasantly surprised that I didn't hate it - but it did nothing to prepare me for how great she is in this film. I also saw her host SNL and she was a natural. I think you're right, this will be the film that turns Lohan into a big star.

Gail Brunswick

Gail Brunswick

I took my teenage girls to this film fully expecting to spend most of the film checking my watch, but to be honest i think i laughed harder than they did. Even though it's been years since my high school days it's clear to see that the social strata system hasn't changed much and I really related to this film. It was exptremely well written and other than one scene toward the end that didn't ring quite true, i think it's the funniest film of the year. And after sitting through that other Lohan film Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen I was more than surprised.

Adam

Adam

So I was covering the Coachella Music and Arts Festival down in Palm Springs (a report will be up on the music page soon) when Mean Girls opened, so I didn't get to check it out. Thankfully, The Boneman had some free time on his hands. Not only did he see this picture, but he also took a bullet for the team in the form of Envy. In my defense, I did sit through Godsend and Laws of Attraction.

After finally seeing Mean Girls, one thing is perfectly clear. This movie was far and away the best thing to come out on that particular weekend.

What I really admired about Mean Girls was how damned smart and satirical Tina Fey's screenplay was. It wasn't Election smart mind you, but it was leaps and bounds better than many other high school comedies.

I loved how nearly every high school social clique was represented, and while at the surface, some of this stuff may have seemed stereotypical, it certainly isn't when you remember what it was like to be a teenager (hopefully, I'll be backed up by teenage readers out there).

Lindsay Lohan is pretty good here. In fact, it's probaby her best work to date. She's cute and likable, and while her transformation from good soul to evil "Plastic" isn't quite gradual enough, she pulls this role off.

And how about Rachel McAdams. I predict big things for this actress. She's probably most known (by the few that saw her in it) for playing the young lady that switches places with Rob Schneider in The Hot Chick. She's a lot of fun here as the queen of the snooty "Plastics". I think audiences will see her in a completely new light when they check her dramatic chops out in the upcoming "The Notebook" (check out our review in 2004).

Mean Girls is very entertaining. It's fun, edgy and sweet in many ways. Besides, I can't dislike a movie in which a character proclaims that their favorite movie of all time is "Varsity Blues". That's hilarious in itself.

On an interesting side note, "Mean Girls" director Mike Waters is brother of Daniel Waters of "Heathers" fame. While "Heathers" is certainly darker, both films seem to be cut from the same cloth.

Grade: B

Meany

Meany

I thought it was a great movie.

Jual

Jual

I hope Tina Fey continues to write more movies, because one is not enough, yo snap

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!