zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Sideways (2004)

Sideways
"There's no problem officer - I'm just the guy from Wings and the dude driving is Pig Vomit . . . y'know the blue guy from Big Fat Liar."

Starring:

Paul Giamatti
Thomas Haden Church
Virginia Madsen
Sandra Oh

Released By:

Fox Searchlight

Released In:

2004

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

A


Sideways is a stunning achievement for writer director Alexander Payne, an insightful film maker who fashioned the picture perfect high school expose with Election as well as the funny but ultimately heartbreaking character study About Schmidt.

The new film Sideways is based on a book by Rex Pickett, and features the sensational Paul Giamatti as Miles Raymond, a middle school teacher/wine taster trying to come to grips with a marriage gone bad. As a means to help get on with his life, Miles decides to plan an excursion for he and his pal Jack (a hilariously selfish Thomas Haden Church), a professional actor who, as fate would have it, is getting married and wants one last big hurrah. Rather than throwing the typical bachelor party, Miles opts to take a week long road trip through wine country with his good friend. And naturally, when they arrive at their destination, all sorts of trouble ensues when Jack decides he want's to sew his wild oats.

Sideways pretty much defies description as it is a fusion of several different styles. It's a character study, it's a buddy film, it's a road movie, it's a comedy, it's a drama, and it's also a tragedy in many ways. Miraculously, Payne weaves all these elements together to form one of the richest film experiences of the year. It's quite amazing that something that looks like it will be so basic is anything but. It is the little moments in this picture, the tiny nuances that make it so grand.

While it is the considerable talents of Payne that ultimately fashion what the movie becomes, it is also a film about performance. Paul Giamatti is a rising star, and I firmly believe he will become one of the greats. If you're unfamiliar with his work, check out his dynamic comical chops in Private Parts or be witness to his amazing breakthrough turn in last year's outstanding American Splendor. In Sideways, he plays the lovable schlub to the absolute hilt. He's funny and eccentric, but it is his internal pain that really comes across. This is a man who has been beaten down by life, but is fully aware that he himself is mostly to blame for the problems he encounters. Giamatti has so many outstanding moments in this picture it's hard to single out highlights, but I was most moved by a monologue in which while deftly describing the Pinot grape, he soon realizes that he's describing himself. An amazing sequence that works it's magic because of a truly remarkable performance.

Thomas Haden Church is a riot as Jack, a man who appears to be Miles' polar opposite on the surface. Church takes absolute relish in playing up this character's bad boy image (odd given that this actor is perhaps best known for his role as the innocent goofball Lowell on TV's Wings), and to Miles' dismay (as well as the audience's) this despicable moron nearly gets away with every inconceivable act he takes part in. But the swiftest trick Church pulls off with this complex role, is that he manages to somehow keep Jack likable. Sure, we know most of what this guy does is wrong, but we never truly hate him.

The most surprising revelation in Sideways comes in the form of a gorgeous and solid Virginia Madsen. While this actress has popped up on screen in everything from Highlander 2 to Candyman, never has she really had the chance to shine. She gets that chance here and makes the most of it. While the film isn't really about her sweet and independent Maya, and while she doesn't log in tons of screen time, she's so effective in her moments that I was constantly thinking of her even when she wasn't on screen. And given that Maya becomes the twinkle in Miles' eye, it all makes perfect sense. It would seem odd that she and Giamatti would have such wonderful on-screen chemistry, but they do. They're absolute dynamite. And watching and listening to Madsen intimately describe why she loves wine so much damn near made me fall in love with her.

No matter how dark or absurd or crazy Sideways became (and it does get dark, absurd, and crazy), it never lost me. Payne allows this film and it's characters to breathe (if you'll pardon the pun), and I was immensely entertained by it. I was somewhat shocked by all the crap that Jack gets away with by the end of this movie, but that's life I suppose. What I really responded to though was Giamatti's Miles, a man who most of us can relate to. While he's put through the emotional ringer throughout Sideways, it was nice to see a little light at the end of the tunnel.

Alexander Payne's latest is an American original and that in of itself is an absolute miracle given all the remakes and rehash we've seen as of late. And like the beverage that it so eloquently described throughout the film, Sideways will only get better with age.

On a side note, I'd like to give a special shout out to Fox Searchlight Pictures. What a great year they're having. Sure, they released one of the worst pictures of the year in the form of Johnson Family Vacation but they more than rebounded with the likes of Napoleon Dynamite, Kinsey, I Heart Huckabees, Garden State, and now, Sideways. Cheers to Fox Searchlight!

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Jessica Lippman

Jessica Lippman

What a sly little masterpiece this film is - I'd like to see it get an Oscar nom.

What a Payne

What a Payne

Payne can do no wrong. What a perfect pairing with Payne and Giamatti. At last he's found a role where the promise he showed in Duets, and American Splendor can be fully fleshed out. PG makes the most of this opportunity and I will be surprised if he doesn't at least get nominated for this performance. And I couldn't be happier for Virginia Madsen, who actually retired from acting for nealy a dozen years in order to raise children, and has returned as matured as the wine that she so eloquently extols. Sideways is among the top 3 films of the year - in my opinion.

Jinx

Jinx

I would love to see Virginia Madsen get nominated for her performance in Sideways - it's just so good to have her back.

Sideways all the way

Sideways all the way

Sideways soars, at first I was disappointed to see it steal all of Eternal Sunshine's thunder (it had my vote for Oscar all year) but having seen it twice now I believe it to be a richer film that literally bursts with wit and intelligence - Bravo Alexander Payne.

Melinda Reese

Melinda Reese

I adored this movie and was very happy to see it win so many golden globe awards. I think Viginia Madsen should get an Oscar nod - here's hoping.

Phil

Phil

What a beautiul movie this really is, I'm so stoked that it won so many awards, I was happy to see Virginia Madsen and Hadyden Church get back on the map.

cmn

cmn

This is definitely not a movie I would take even my approved age teenager to view. It was one of the worse movies I have seen this year, and I go to the movies just about every weekend. The plot was boring and disjointed, and the nudity was plain crude.

Sir Dizzy

Sir Dizzy

Miles Faymond (Giamatti), is a divorced middle school teacher and failed novelist, and his altar-bound friend Jack (Thomas Haden Church) who was once a fairly prominent actor and now has been reduced to a commercial actor to just make a living take a wine-tasting trip in California, pondering questions about their directions in life. The wine tasting road trip is to salute Jack's final days as a bachelor careens woefully sideways as he and Miles hit the gas en route to mid-life crises. The comically mismatched pair, who share little more than their history and a heady blend of failed potential and fading youth, soon find themselves drowning in wine and women (Sandra Oh and Virginia Madsen). Emerging from a haze of pinot noir, wistful yearnings and trepidation about the future, the two inevitably collide with reality.

Very few movies live up to all the hype around them, but Sideways comes fairly close, as the movie is clever, funny and highly entertaining. I laughed throughout the movie; sometimes almost falling on the ground with laughter and when I was not laughing I was highly amused by all the little quirks of the characters and what was happening on the screen. The movie has a very smart script and a biting wit on life and all the little things that make life up. It uses its two characters to show quirks in all of us and how amusing our habits and obsessions can be. If anyone has ever been obsessed with anything, like I am with movies and like Miles was with wine, its hard to not only find the humor on the screen but as well as in our own lives. While Jack on the other hand is the dark side in all of us, he lets go and is free like many people might wish to be despite the consequences and without Miles would probably be an absolute wreck. The movie does all this while it makes you laugh; the gold scene was one of the funniest I have ever seen in a movie.

Paul Giamatti and Thomas Haden Church both do a superb job at their parts. You see them as Miles and Jack not two actors asked to do parts, and they add depth to already deep characters probably giving the characters life from their own personal experience. Thomas Haden Church who plays a TV actor who was once popular and now has been reduced to commercials is probably quite close to what has happened to Church since he left his popular TV show wings. You cannot help being drawn into these characters and caring for them all the while laughing at the crazy things they do. The movie is definitely worth an Oscar nomination and is one of those movies that you will remember for a long time, as the movie was ingenious, smart and funny.

jen johnson

jen johnson

After much hype I finally saw Sideways. What a disappointment!!!! It had several amusing moments and good character studies, but it was extremely vulgar and boring in many parts. Middle age male anxiety....who cares? It did not hold my interest! Alcoholics would probably like this film because it makes it seem that wine tasting and, by extension, drinking to excess is quite funny , acceptable and sophisticated even. Not so! The acting was better than average but the premise of the movie was not. A whole movie about nothing or wine (or whine). No thanks!

The Boneman

The Boneman

Jen, I would respectfully take exception to parts of your analysis of Sideways. You seemed to infer that the film glorifies male misbehavior, as well as alcoholism. If anything I think the film goes out of it's way to make the very entertaining but unmistakable point that alcoholism and/or midlife crises are terribly pathetic and self-destructive. I think Payne is merely demonstrating how many different types of weaknesses the male of the species have and that ultimately the ways men choose to insulate themselves from the pain of their problems and insecurities only end up making matters worse. And in the end Payne left room for us all to hope that us testosterone-addled fools might have it in us to improve ourselves.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!