zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Spartan (2004)

Spartan
After Wonderland and the Salton Sea, it's nice to see Val all spiffed up again.

Starring:

Val Kilmer
Derek Luke
Kristen Bell
William H. Macy and Tia Texada

Released By:

Warner Brothers

Released In:

2004

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

B+


Spartan is the latest film from writer/director David Mamet, a legendary playwright who I believe to be one of the finest screenwriters of the last twenty years (I would rank him among the likes of Quentin Tarantino and Steven Zallian).

The twisty, turvy Spartan features Val Kilmer as U.S. government Special Agent Scott, a tough military man who is assigned the seemingly impossible task of finding and rescuing the kidnapped daughter of a high-profile politcal figure. To find her, he must survive a series of double crosses and heartpounding shockers.

Leave it to Mamet to fashion a thriller that actually offers up sufficient surprises, but in an understated, realistic manner. This is an unpredictable suspense yarn with three dimensional characters instead of propped-up cardboard cut-outs, and that in itself is quite refreshing.

Mamet (who also penned the brilliant Glengarry Glen Ross) is well known for the rather strange, unique rhythm of his dialogue. This is something that tends to turn many people off (I personally find it compelling). When you see a Mamet movie or read a Mamet play, there is always something distinctively Mamet about it. The sometimes odd manner in which the characters of his universe talk, is the veteran's trademark and I wouldn't have it any other way. As is the case with most of Mamet's projects, Spartan is extremely talkie and chalk full of colorful wordplay, (although it should be noted that the use of the "F" word is not nearly as prominent as it's been in some of his past pictures).

Mamet has also emerged as an outstanding director through the years (see State and Main, Winslow Boy, and The Spanish Prisoner). Spartan is clearly his most restrained work, and while that trademark dialogue is present, there isn't quite as much of it.

The neatest trick in Spartan, is the manner in which the action unfolds. Mamet has written the piece in a way that the audience kind of figures things out as the characters do, and this makes the proceedings extremely exciting. It's also clear that Mamet is using elements of real life in this understated political thriller (I couldn't help but think that the kidnapped girl is somehow loosely based on one of George W. Bush's infamous daughters), some of which made me sick to my stomach. Mamet kept making me ask myself, "at what point does one place his own career and global responsibility over that of a loved one?

Val Kilmer is solid as the cold and callous marine who, beneath it all, does have a heart. Derek Luke (who made a huge impression in Antwone Fisher) is outstanding as Kilmer's right hand man. Kristen Bell steals the show as the kidnapped victim - a sad, lonely soul whose yearning for love and self identity gets her into a world of peril. This is the first thing I've seen this young actress in and she sort of reminds me of Matchstick Men's Alison Lohman. Her vulnerable portrayal of Laura Newton lends a huge boost of dramatic energy to the brisk and bristling Spartan. For whatever reason, Rebecca Pidgeon (a Mamet film regular) is nowhere to be found among the terrific cast.

There were moments in this picture that didn't quite work for me. Kilmer's verbal exchange with Tia Texada toward the end of the film felt overly melodramatic and out of character. Ultimately, though, Spartan is alive and unpredictable (complete with a bittersweet ending) and with the brilliant Mamet at the helm, it's that all-too-rare breed of thriller; one with surprises.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Kristy Jenkins

Kristy Jenkins

What ever happened to this film? After all it had a terrific cast, a story even more compelling than the one in Man on Fire and yet it was in and out of town before I had a chance to look it up in the paper. Was it limited release or what?

Adam

Adam

Kristy,

Unfortunately, nobody went to see Spartan. It just didn't develop any kind of word of mouth which is really disappointing. I agree, it was far more compelling than Man on Fire. Like I said in my review, I think David Mammet is one of the best screenwriters of the last twenty years. His diaogue is incredibly creative, and he's proven to be quite the director as well. Hopefully, this picture will find an audience on DVD and video. After I saw it, I told everyone I knew to check it out. Sometimes good movies get lost in the shuffle.

Tarzan

Tarzan

I just rented this one the other night and I have to say, it's pretty much the first time I've ever liked Thomas Jane in anything. Coincidentally, a few nights prior I watched Under Suspicion and he was just Godawful in that.

Emily Stoper

Emily Stoper

You'll like "Spartan" if you appreciate a shootout roughly every 10 minutes in which at least one person is killed for reasons that are entirely unclear. Eventually, some of the killings will be explained, but the explanations will seem plausible to you only if you accept the movie's unspoken premise: The world's a very dangerous place, full of evil people - and the only way to survive in it is to shoot first and ask questions later. The protagonist, played by Val Kilmer, has mastered the art of doing this and never letting the bloody consequences get to him emotionally. About three-quarters of the way through, a twist in the plot implied that the Kilmer character actually cares about another human being. But Kilmer's tight-lipped acting style never changes and the periodic shootings continue, so this shift never seems real. I found this moving gratuitously violent, contrived, implausible and boring. I wish Hollywood wouldn't waste good talent on such noxious material.

Adam

Adam

Tarzan,

I have a simialr felling about Thomas Jane. However, check him out in a film called Stander. A brilliant performance.

Emily,

I'll have to agree to disagree. I'll take the subtlety of Spartan over the excess of a movie like Bad Boys 2 any day of the week. Sorry you didn't care for it though.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!