zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

The Manchurian Candidate (2004)

The Manchurian Candidate
In an unexpcted and ill-thought-out attempt to ease the tension on the set of this psychological pot-boiler, Denzel takes a whiz on Meryl Streep.

Starring:

Denzel Washington
Meryl Streep
Liev Shrieber

Released By:

Paramount Pictures

Released In:

2004

Rated:

R

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

B-


The Manchurian Candidate is another in a long line of remakes to come out in the past couple of years. Another appropriate title for the film might have been The Stepford Candidate as it features plot elements that are quite similar to the recent Frank Oz film (which also happened to be a remake). In all seriousness, this updated version of the classic film from 1962 is far better than The Stepford Wives, and for what it's worth, it isn't a half bad remake either. That, in itself is a miracle, when you consider that the original is a masterpiece that never should have been disturbed in the first place.

This tale of conspiracy and paranoia features Denzel Washington as Ben Marco, a U.S. Army Captain who continues to be haunted by nightmarish visions caused by an experience in the Gulf War. Liev Schreiber is Raymond Shaw, a man whose life is on an upswing following receiving the medal of honor for his heroics while fighting under the command of Marco. Years have past, and as Marco's horrible visions continue, Shaw's popularity begins to grow in the public eye as he is mere steps away from obtaining the Vice Presidency of the United States - but not without the help of his overbearing and all-too-driven mother Eleanor Shaw (Meryl Streep). Marco soon begins to question the cause of his nightmares, and his investigation brings him to a dangerous conclusion that may include Shaw and the other men who served under him during the war.

The Manchurian Candidate was directed by the terrific Jonathan Demme (Silence of the Lambs) whose last attempt at remaking a classic resulted in the dreadful The Truth About Charlie (an update of the wonderful Charade). While this picture is leaps and bounds better than that awful mess, it can't hold a candle to 1962 version. Still, he deserves his props for a worthy effort in a re-telling what manages to be far more effective than the likes of Gus Van Sant's pointless take on Psycho.

Denzel Washington is solid as Ben Marco. As a haunted soul, Washington perfectly conveys a sense of paranoia, loneliness, and utter confusion. Liev Schrieber (an actor I'm really starting to warm up to) is outstanding as Raymond Shaw. He offers up a "creepy under the surface," robotic kind of vibe to the role, but he's also sympathetic and excels in moments of true drama. While his turn here is not as memorable as Laurence Harvey's in the oriental (he played the role as more of a momma's boy), I thought he was terrific nonetheless. I had been bothered by Meryl Streep's take on Eleanor Shaw (played by the wonderful Angela Lansbury in the original) since seeing her ham it up in the trailers. She really looked to be overplaying the role. But watching her in the context of the film, I found her fun and completely over-the-top in an Al Pacino kind of way, and I loved the little nuances that she brings to the role of this political zealot (most notably a strange kind of tension between she and Raymond towards the end of the film). Finally, I want to give a shout out to the amazing Jeffrey Wright, who continues to dazzle the hell out of me with each passing role. While he's only in the film for a few minutes, he make the most of them as a worn out soldier named Al Melvin. .

I like the way this Manchurian Candidate unfolds. We learn information as Denzel does and this sort of plot structure keeps the audience on their feet. I also like the nightmarish visions as shot by Jonathan Demme. The dreams, flashbacks and brain tampering sequences are downright chilling.

The Manchurian Candidate really loses something in the mid section and some of the updated elements are a little too obvious (such as one of the big enemies being a large corporation), but I was surprised how engrossed I was for much of the movie. It's well acted, well shot and ripe with a surprising amount of tension. And I absolutely loved how the climax unfolds.

The Manchurian Candidate is far from perfect (the idea that behind every great man is his mother is a little silly--at least in this version) and as I previously stated, it pales in comparison to the original, but for the most part, I quite liked it. It's much smarter than standard summer fare. If you're looking for a little intrigue in a movie this weekend (and if The Bourne Supremacy has already started by the time you get to the theater), go check out The Manchurian Candidate.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Sharon Welch

Sharon Welch

Though it's based on the same novel (by Richard Condon) that turned into the classic 1962 black-and-white film, the makers of this new "Manchurian Candidate" might have been better off naming their film something else. Anything else. Adam is right to point out that the original was a superior film.

Though the the two movies do share plot points and characters, they are extremely different, and this updated adaptation or loose remake or whatever it is, does deserve to be taken on its own merits, rather than being the subject of endless comparisons. It too is a good film.

Heidi Poulson

Heidi Poulson

Adam makes a good point, but I believe that Demme's work on this film is good enough to allow us to forgive him — well, almost — for "The Truth About Charlie."

There's an almost overwhelming atmosphere of dread hanging over the film. And Washington is as solid and forceful as ever — when he needs to be. Schreiber's performance might seem a bit bland, but I guess that's really the point of his character. And it should come as no surprise that the real scene-stealer here is Streep, who appears to be paying tribute to Angela Lansbury's performance in the original, as well as mimicking Hillary Rodham Clinton. She plays this stage mother like and inexorable force of nature and her perfromance alone is enough to recommend the film

Ian Hughes

Ian Hughes

I agree with Mr. Mast, Meryl Streep is not only over-the-top she devours the scenery, and Demme is to be commended for allowing her such wide berth. However, I think Demme lets Washington down. He puts in a strong performance as Macro, but, as Washington is attempting to show us Marco's sleep deprivation, mental turmoil, and increasing, possibly justifiable, paranoia, Demme doesn't give him enough of a chance to explain the behavior. I think Demme needed to show us a little more about what is going on in Marco's life, the sleepless nights, his dedication to the Army that turns it's back on him, etc. This would have made Washington's performance easier to understand and appreciate. Physically and mentally, Washington performs, but I think it gets lost on members of the audience who aren't familiar with the story.

Long Live Liev

Long Live Liev

I've read Adam's review and all of these comments, but no one has pointed out how good of a job Schreiber did. In the original Manchurian Candidate, Laurence Harvey played Raymond Shaw as a jerk, but Schreiber makes the character more complex and sympathetic, even magnetic and charismatic at times. He makes us believe Shaw wants to do the right thing, if he could just figure out what the right thing is supposed to be. It's another fine performance from an underrated, under appreciated actor.

Brad Miner

Brad Miner

This film is slow, dialog laden, pretentious, and bears little or no relationship to the book. A terrible waste of money. What I want to know is why the critics say this is so good, Is it because Denzel Washington is in it? cos his performance is sadly lacking, Glen Close play a wonderful Hilary Clinton! I conclude that the studio who pays the most gets the best reviews.

Help me Adam!

Help me Adam!

I thought I followed the plot pretty well, but at the end I did not understand what or who's side Marco and Rosie were on. What did I miss?

Mark Bloom

Mark Bloom

I quite liked this film and felt like your review was right on the money - however I didn't like the caption about Denzel pissing on Streep - I LOVED it. Keep up the good work. Love the site

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!