I've never been much of a fan of Nick Cassavetes. She's So Lovely was a good movie but I wouldn't say I loved it. John Q was a movie I loathed with it's unfair and all-too-bitter look at health care. Ultimately, it was a film about terrorism and featured far too many irrelevant characters. It didn't seem to stick to it's main issue.
Suffice it to say, I didn't know what to think going into The Notebook. I knew nothing about the plot of the film. I was aware that it starred Ryan Gosling, James Garner, and Joan Allen but that was about it. After doing a little research, I discovered that names like Steven Spielberg, Jim Sheridan and Tom Cruise were once attached to it.
As The Notebook opens, James Garner appears as a sweet old gentleman who, through the aid of a notebook, hopes to help a woman (played by Gena Rowlands) suffering from Allzheimer's disease, remember who she is.
Through a flashback, we are taken back to North Carolina, JUne 6, 1940 and introduced to Noah Calhoun (played by Ryan Gosling), a soft spoken, adventurous young man who meets his female counterpart in the form of Allie Nelson (played by Rachel McAdams). The two have much in common and quickly fall for one another, but their union doesn't go over well with Allie's overbearing mother, who has bigger dreams for her vibrant and promising daughter.
The Notebook is one of those films in which the material could have gone either way. The screenplay could have been incredibly sappy and overly melodramatic had it fallen into the wrong actors' hands, but happily, the cast transcend the material and make it much deeper than it actually is.
Ryan Gosling is a star on the rise. He was outstanding in The Believer and equally effective in the upcoming United States of Leland. With The Notebook, the dynamic actor (who reminds me of a young Sean Penn) plays the romantic lead and he does so with understated power. Of course it takes two to tango and Rachel McAdams proves to be the perfect leading lady. This lovely young actress has appeared in The Hot Chick and the soon to be released Mean Girls, but after this, I'm sure more dramatic work will come her way. Through a gorgeous smile and a lively, energetic performance, McAdams brings this passionate young woman to life. She and Gosling have perfect chemistry and they bring weight and dimension to The Notebook.
Joan Allen is outstanding as Allie's meddeling and somewhat callous mother. Ultimately, however, there is a reason for her actions, and while this isn't altogether a fair excuse, Allen brings humanity to this part, so that it's really hard to dislike her.
James Garner is spectacular in an all too small role. As a man caring for a less fortunate woman, the veteran actor packs an emotional punch. This is his best work in years. When he broke down on screen, I nearly broke down with him.
The Notebook is very observant in it's look at youth, passion and love. The Garner/Rowlands relationship has shades of the recent 50 First Dates, only it isn't bogged down by horrid, infintile humor (thank God!). It opts to take a more serious route.
Midway through the picture, The Notebook plot thickens by introducing a love triangle, and it's simiar to the one in Michael Bay's ridiculously overbloated Pearl Harbor. Thankfully, the relationships on display here are far more realistic. What I liked most about this triangle is that I actually believed Allie could be in love with both of these men. While Noah is certainly a more developed character than the new man (X-Men's James Marsden) in Allie's life, I still bought into it, because of the intervening circumstances.
The Notebook won't be for everyone. Some will find it a little too sticky sweet, but for me, the strong acting took this movie to a higher level. It's certainly the best thing Nick Cassavettes has done.
:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::