zBoneman.com -- Home Movie Reviews

Wicker Park (2004)

Wicker Park
"I need your honest opionion. They're making a film based on the old TV show My Three Sons, and they offered me the role of Chip - good career move?"

Starring:

Josh Hartnett
Rose Byrne
Diane Kruger and Matthew Lillard

Released By:

MGM

Released In:

2004

Rated:

PG-13

Reviewed By:

Adam Mast

Grade:

C+


Wicker Park is being advertised as a thriller. Don't be fooled. This is no more a thriller than The Village is a tale about monsters, although in the early goings on, the movie does kind of lead you to believe it might be a mystery of sorts. In actuality, it is but not the type you might think.

What Wicker Park really is, is a story about people and the strange fashion in which they act after being bit by the love bug. To actually go into detail on the plot would be a tad difficult as this picture is quite complex (perhaps too complex for it's own good), and I couldn't really go into depth without giving certain things away. Just know that despite it's complexity, it's easy to understand as you watch it. The focal point of the film is Matthew (Josh Hartnett), a twenty something embarking on a career, who suddenly finds himself sidetracked by love. Before long, Matthew realizes he's caught in a strange web of deception orchestrated by someone who has more in common with him than he might care to admit.

Through the first forty minutes or so of Wicker Park, I started to feel like I was watching an extended ad for Obsession perfume. Stylistically speaking, much of the movie is staged and shot like one of those commercials (close-ups of brooding faces and such), but even more importantly, obsession plays an all important role in the movie. In fact, it got to a point when I felt like no one in the picture truly loved each other. They were more in love with the idea of being in love.

As the movie continued to unfold, the proceedings became somewhat silly, but surprisingly, the movie does have some smarts, particularly in the final act in which certain characters see how selfish they've been and begin to realize the error of their ways.

I've always had a hard time getting into Josh Hartnett. I don't hate the guy, but beyond his work in Black Hawk Down, he has yet to really impress me (although he does look pretty darn good in the upcoming Sin City). There's something rather dull about the way he carries himself, and of the large batch of twenty something actors currently making names for themselves, I'd call him more James Franco than Ryan Gosling. His Matthew never really moved me and I never felt myself rooting for him.

Diane Kruger is a beauty, but ultimately, we never really get to know her Lisa. This role feels underwritten, and this is strange given that it is her character that sort of sets the whole story into motion.

The strongest performance in Wicker Park comes from Rose Byrne as the lonely and vulnerable Alex. She brings desperation and a sense of yearning to the role of an actress with self confidence issues (so much so in fact, that she begins to take on a "Single White Female" kind of persona), and while there were certainly moments that could have been overplayed here, she does an admirable job (save for a scene in which she performs in a play midway through the movie--embarrassing).

In all honesty, I was bored stiff during the first half of this picture. Nothing seemed to be happening and I was irritated by the over the top direction by Paul McGuigan (who does a couple of annoying spiral camera moves that appear inspired by the overly flashy Man On Fire). But then, in the second half of the picture, Wicker Park becomes a little more observant, and I was pleased that the film doesn't turn into a routine mystery as the trailer suggests it might. Instead, Wicker Park builds on it's characters' little white lies, which ultimately become bigger and threaten the lives of these confused people.

The numerous coincidences and connections between the various characters may be hard for some to swallow, but as the film moves along, it becomes easier to digest. And I enjoyed the sequences in which director McGuigan doubles back to previous scenes from a different perspective (ala Jackie Brown). In some movies, such trickery is intrusive, but here, it works to the film's advantage.

The ending of the picture is bittersweet (and a tad too tidy) and I can't say that I completely bought into it, but I admired the honesty that these characters ultimately display. I call the climax bittersweet because two of the most genuine players in the film get the shaft. But then, that's life I suppose. Nice people often finish last.

Wicker Park is slow rather than patient, and to me, there's a big difference between the two. I'm all for a patient movie provided there's an element of intrigue or characters worth caring about. Nothing really happens here until we get into hour two, and while I suppose it could be argued that the first half is the all important set up, I found it rather lifeless and full of characters who were obsessing rather than actually falling in love. Thankfully, the second half of the picture brings a little more depth to the table.

There have been better movies about obsession and the pros and cons that come with a relationship (Stanley Kubrick's astonishing and underrated Eyes Wide Shut for one), but Wicker Park ended up being more fascinating than I initially though it would be.

:: zBoneman.com Reader Comments ::

Curious George

Curious George

Since you don't have a place to type stuff in on the humor part I just wanted to say that that last bit with the evil lesbians is one of the most hilarious things I've ever read is that chick for real or what?

The Boneman

The Boneman

George, Maddy is my niece who occasionally favors us with the bizarre events in her life, soon we're going to fix that part of the site so it works like the movies and music, thanks I'll pass along the kind words.

MIA

MIA

I notice that Josh Hartnet has been MIA for some time, choosing to skip the teen hunk status in favor of small, intimate projects that make him happy. Nice for him, stinks for us.

Shane

Shane

Wicker Park offers a handful of pseudo-clever moments that manage carry it to its lengthy finish line. But wooden performances (in particular pretty-face-turned-actress Kruger), and one too many plot twists turn wicker park into Dorky park

Tom Shelton

Tom Shelton

Say what you will about Mathew Lillard - but he was the best thing about this movie and offered a little comic relief when it was badly needed.

Vickie

Vickie

Josh Hartnett sees Diane Kruger on a Chicago street and immediately falls in love with her; Rose Bryne sees Josh on a street and immediately falls in love with him; Matthew Lillard, josh's friend, falls in love with any good-looking women who walk into his shoe store. When he meets Alex, he immediately falls in love with her. About this time I fell out of love with wicker park,

virgil

virgil

The premise of WICKER PARK hails Mankind's new evolutionary mandate: Beauty is power. It used to be about providing food and being able to kill one's rival for a fertile mate. Now, you can get anything you want if you are beautiful.

fran webb

fran webb

I loved MEMENTO and THE USUAL SUSPECTS, but WICKER PARK made me work so damn hard figuring out what - in the Good Lord's Name - was going on that it was mentally exhausting and unnecessarily frustrating. It was not a murder mystery but a ridiculous love story! This thin g stinks on ice

Jimmy Rogers

Jimmy Rogers

Wicker Park couldn't have been less interestng if it were a 2 hour guided tour through Pier One imports

Cellular

Cellular

Here is the problem every audience member must tackle sitting through this movie and the one problem the screenwriter could not surmount: Even children now have cell phones. The fact that Lisa suddenly vanishes nearly ruins Hartnetts emotional life. Yes, he becomes successful and gets his boss's sister as an almost fiancé, but he is still in love with Lisa. It's been two years since she left. Instead of emailing him or calling his cell, she leaves him a note with a girlfriend - Alex.

Rodney Cosslet

Rodney Cosslet

This film actually damaged my brain - I wanted to stay up on what I thought were important twists and turns and then it turns out to be a sappy romance - enough to give you a migraine.

Hartnett Sinking

Hartnett Sinking

Matthew returns to Chicago and thinks he spies Lisa running out of a restaurant. So what he chucks his business trip to Hong Kong and searches for her. This involves doing dumb things like sleeping in someone else's hotel room and searching a stranger's apartment. When we actually find out what is going on, it is a big, silly disappointment. An apt microcosm of the film in general. Hartnett is sinking fast in my bookl

Carl Miller

Carl Miller

In order to enjoy this film you have to convince yourself that we live in a world that has banned cell phones

Bart Johnson

Bart Johnson

Wicker Park shoots itself in the foot by trying to be too clever for it's own goood.

Add your own comment here and see it posted immediately!